Kettle Dyed vs Hand Painted vs Immersion Dyed Yarn: What's the Difference?
Share
Kettle dyed yarn, hand painted yarn, immersion dyed yarn. If you've spent any time browsing hand dyed yarn UK shops, you'll have seen these terms on labels and product pages. They describe how the colour got onto the yarn, and that matters more than you might think, because the method shapes how the colour sits in the skein and how it behaves once you start knitting or crocheting.
This guide walks through the three most common hand dyed yarn techniques, what each one tends to look like, and what that means for the fabric you make. If you'd like the bigger picture of the whole process, from choosing a base to rinsing and drying, our post on how hand dyed yarn is made covers it step by step.
A quick note on the terms
Yarn dyeing techniques don't come with an official rulebook. Different dyers use the same words in slightly different ways, and one dyer's kettle dyeing might be another's low immersion. The descriptions below are the most common meanings, so treat them as a helpful guide rather than strict definitions. If a label isn't clear, the photos and the dyer's own description will usually tell you more.
Immersion dyeing: calm, even colour
With immersion dyeing, the whole skein goes into a dye bath with plenty of water and is heated gently until the yarn has taken up the dye. Because the yarn can move freely and the colour reaches every part of it, immersion dyed yarn is usually the most even of the three.
What it looks like in the skein: solid, semi solid or tonal colour, often with gentle shifts in depth rather than distinct sections. Immersion dyeing is behind many of the rich, deep semi solid shades you'll see from indie dyers.
What it looks like in your fabric: calm and cohesive. Tonal yarn gives knitted fabric a quiet depth without pooling or striping, so it's a lovely choice for cables, lace, textured stitches and large garments where you want the stitches to take centre stage.
What is hand painted yarn?
Hand painted yarn is dyed by laying the damp skein out flat and applying colour directly to sections of it, with brushes, squeeze bottles or spoons. This gives the dyer the most control over where each colour sits.
What it looks like in the skein: clearly defined sections of colour. Hand painting is how many multi-coloured variegated skeins are made, along with gradients and skeins dyed to stripe in a particular way.
What it looks like in your fabric: lively and full of movement. Depending on your stitch count, those colour sections can form short flashes, stripes or pools of colour. Hand painted yarn often looks its best in simple stitches, where the colour does the work, and in projects with a narrow width, such as socks, mitts and cowls.
What is kettle dyed yarn?
Kettle dyed yarn is usually dyed in a pot or shallow pan with less water and less stirring than full immersion dyeing. Colour is added to the pot and allowed to take unevenly, so some parts of the skein soak up more dye than others. As our beginner's guide to hand dyed yarn puts it, kettle dyeing simmers yarn in a pot, giving semi solid tones with natural variation built in.
What it looks like in the skein: soft, blended colour with a watercolour feel. Shades drift into each other rather than sitting in neat sections, so you might see darker and lighter patches, or two or three colours melting together.
What it looks like in your fabric: organic and painterly. Kettle dyed wool tends to give gentle variation across the fabric without the strong striping you might get from hand painted yarn, which makes it a happy middle ground between tonal and variegated.
Kettle dyeing and low immersion dyeing
You'll often see low immersion dyeing (or low water immersion dyeing) mentioned alongside kettle dyeing. Both rely on using less water and leaving the yarn fairly still, so the dye can't spread evenly, and many dyers use the two terms to mean much the same thing. If you like the look of one, you'll very likely enjoy the other.
Where does speckled yarn fit in?
Speckling isn't really a fourth method so much as a finishing touch. Small dots or flicks of concentrated dye are added to the yarn, often on top of an immersion dyed, kettle dyed or undyed base. The result is that confetti effect so many knitters and crocheters love. We look at how speckled, tonal and variegated yarns each behave once knitted in our guide to speckled vs tonal vs variegated yarn.
How we dye at Blewbury Yarns
We mainly immersion dye, using low, mid or high immersion depending on the colourway. In other words, we change how much water goes into the dye bath to get the effect we're after. In a high immersion bath the yarn has plenty of room and the colour spreads evenly, giving calm, tonal shades. Mid immersion leaves a little more variation, and low immersion dyeing uses much less water, so the colour takes up unevenly and you get softer, more blended and variegated effects. That's why our skeins can range from quiet tonals to colourways with lots of movement, even though they all start in a dye bath.
Choosing between kettle dyed, hand painted and immersion dyed yarn
When you're choosing yarn for a project, the dyeing method is a helpful clue to how the finished piece will look:
- For textured stitches, cables and lace, immersion dyed tonal or semi solid yarn lets your stitch pattern shine.
- For simple stitches and bold colour, hand painted yarn brings plenty of movement and interest to plain stocking stitch or garter.
- For gentle variation without strong stripes, kettle dyed yarn sits nicely in between.
-
For large garments, colour that's evenly spread is usually easier to manage across wide body panels. We talk about this more in our guide to hand dyed yarn for jumpers.
Whatever the method, every hand dyed skein is a little different, and no two batches will match exactly. Our post on why small batch yarn is different explains why that variation is part of the appeal.
A note on alternating skeins
If you're using more than one skein of hand painted or kettle dyed yarn in a project, alternating skeins is worth the small extra effort. Working a couple of rows or rounds from one skein and then from the next blends any small differences, so you won't see a line where one skein ends and the next begins. It matters less with immersion dyed tonal yarn, but it's a good habit with any hand dyed yarn. We'll be covering alternating skeins and dye lots in a dedicated guide later this month.
Frequently asked questions
What is kettle dyed yarn?
Kettle dyed yarn is dyed in a pot or pan with relatively little water and little stirring, so the colour takes up unevenly across the skein. The result is soft, blended colour with natural variation, often described as semi solid or watercolour-like.
What is hand painted yarn?
Hand painted yarn is dyed by applying colour directly to sections of a damp skein laid out flat. It gives defined areas of colour and is often used for variegated skeins, which can stripe or pool when knitted or crocheted.
What is immersion dyeing yarn?
Immersion dyeing means placing the whole skein in a dye bath so the colour reaches every part of it. It usually gives the most even result, from solid colour to gentle tonal shading.
Which method is best?
There's no best method, only the right one for your project. Calm, tonal colour suits detailed stitches, while hand painted and kettle dyed yarns shine in simpler patterns that let the colour lead.
Find your next hand dyed yarn
Most of our yarn is 100% superwash merino, a fibre that takes colour beautifully, which is part of why hand dyed shades look so rich on it. You can read more in our guide to superwash vs non-superwash yarn.
When you're ready to put what you've learned into practice, browse our Sock/4ply collection, DK collection or Aran collection. And if you'd like to hear when our next batch lands, along with new guides like this one, you can join our newsletter at the bottom of this page.